I have to admit though he has a few interesting points on the generation of subjects via police and state its apparatuses. Althusserian marxism by nasrullah mambrol on april 12, 2016 12. Mar 17, 2015 to althusser, this also appeared to be an important point within the debates internal to communism at the time, in that it was dominated by the ideological complex he called humanism and economism. In english in 1969 by allen lane, the penguin press. Louis althusser combined marxism with the scientifically oriented methods of structuralism in his essay, ideology and the ideological state apparatuses 1970 and analysed how the dominant systems enforce their control by subtly moulding their subjects through ideology. I recognize that some authors, like marx, at times fall on both sides of the divide, and i will show why this is so. Althusser s version of marxism rejects both economic determinism and humanism. The philosopher advocates the existence of an epistemological break in the intellectual journey of marx, through which the german thinker left behind the ideological concepts that characterize humanism, such as man. Althusser and theoretical antihumanism has 8,221 members. In no sense was i condemning ideology as a social reality as marx says, it is in ideology that men become conscious of their class conflict. Marxist humanism is an international body of thought and political action rooted in an interpretation of the works of karl marx.
There can be no wonder that confusion has reigned over the political interpretation of althussers early theoretical work. Below is a transcript of his conversation with host renato parascandolo, translated by ron salaj. The concept of ideology in marxist literary criticism. The structuralist marxism of louis althusser althussers structuralist approach first emerges in for marx, which brings together his essays on the young marx, dialectics, theater, science, and humanism. The althusser we reread today is no longer the center of those heated polemics and ideological battles that characterized the marxisms of the 1960s and 1970s. Althusser is an interesting guy but i dont think we gain much in understanding the world by reading just another marxist reductionist philosopher. Louis al thusser was born in algeria in 1918 and died in. Althusserian marxism literary theory and criticism. Concerning humanism, sartre, anti humanism, and althusser. Instead of being structured into two levels, althusser argues that society has three levels, or structures. He thought that the marxist tradition was weak on the question of ideology and that marx, even if he possessed the genius to invent the concept, had. So any thought that appeals to marx for any kind of restoration of a theoretical anthropology or humanism is no more. On ideology louis althusser pdf the tenacious obviousnesses ideological obviousnesses of an empiricist type of the point of view of production alone, or even of oilfield technology magazine pdf that of mere terpreted as a conventional sociological theory, ideology is the false representation of the. Althusser was a life long member of the pcf in france and though attacking its humanism in.
Althusser and foucault, 19701975 it is impossible to know anything about men except on the absolute precondition that the philosophical theoretical myth of man is reduced to ashes. This essay concerns the uneasy relationship between althusser and hegel that can be observed throughout althussers oeuvre. Althusser historical materialism 15 2007 153 172 157 disappeared and were replaced by other concepts. He thus moves away from the earlier marxist understanding of ideology. Best known perhaps for his antihumanist interpretation of marx, louis althussers predominant legacy is the critique of hegelian marxism, and infamous analysis that the early writings of marx are trapped within either hegelian or feuerbachian outlooks. Althusser and his influence by ted benton, macmillan, 1984, 257 pages, by lee harvey bentons book is an introductory text on althusser that has two intentions. First, to make althussers work, and that of other althusserians, more accessible. Yze55z5ryw3ziehez5o5wi ziyzmw35aei,w3zhi ziyzowypzie5zt5,whwczy. But he was against it or was antihumanist with reference to stalins errors and crimes.
Althusser rejected two kinds of marxist essentialism. The economic level all of those activities which involve producing something or meeting a need. Marxism as a finite theory 1978 louis althusser i believe that marxist theory is finite, limited. Althusser s influential attack on marxism and the concepts of dialectical development in nature and history. The tendency was born in the 1940s and reached a degree of prominence in the 1950s and 1960s before being largely outshined by the antihumanist marxism of louis althusser. In the late 1950s and the early 1960s, when he wrote these essays, marxismleninism, the french communist party, and the french. For althusser, in turn, marxism is a theoretical anti humanism because basic marxist concepts are unrelated to humanistic notions. The following entry presents an overview of althussers career.
Im developing a greater understanding of existentialism through reading sartre, dostoyevsky, and camus i understand the latter two are not necessarily existentialists, but their contributions are noted. Louis althusser builds on the work of jacques lacan to understand the way ideology functions in society. Marx and engels, however, had pointed out along with many other young hegelians that hegels dialectic not only contradicts but also points beyond the closed system of hegelian philosophy. Althussers version of marxism rejects both economic determinism and humanism. For marxs marxism and humanism, moreover, implicitly criticizes kruschev for social democratic tendencies, even as it offers an uncompromising alternative to stalinist social theory. Inducted into the french army in 1939, althusser was captured by german troops in 1940 and spent the remainder of the war in a german prisoner of war camp. In this context he draws a distinction between science and. Essentialism is a reduction of things to a single principle or essence. Best known perhaps for his antihumanist interpretation of marx, louis althusser s predominant legacy is the critique of hegelian marxism, and infamous analysis that the early writings of marx are trapped within either hegelian or feuerbachian outlooks. Letter to the central committee of the pcf, 18 march 1966.
If this was the version of humanism, althusser accepted, he was antihumanist. Within this western marxism there are, naturally, considerable variations, so that gramsci, for example, can be seen as prefiguring. That will partly depend on what marxism becomes in the new century, and partly on the new postcold war situation of globalization and universal. Under the banner of western marxist scientism were mainly louis althusser in france, dellavolpe and l. Louis althusser did not often given television interviews. Letter to the central committee of the pcf, 18 march 1966 1.
Instead of focusing on the individual worker, althusser s work examines the. Apr 12, 2016 home literary criticism althusserian marxism. One of the more significant of these theories comes from a french marxist, louis althusser, in his 1970 essay, ideology and ideological state apparatuses notes towards an investigation. Louis althusser essays in selfcriticism translated by grahame lock.
The crowning essay is probably dialectical materialism, but i prefer marxism and humanism. Louis althusser, born october 16, 1918, birmandreis, algeriadied october 22, 1990, near paris, france, french philosopher who attained international renown in the 1960s for his attempt to fuse marxism and structuralism inducted into the french army in 1939, althusser was captured by german troops in 1940 and spent the remainder of the war in a german prisoner of war camp. For althusser, marxism is not a humanism based upon the argument that a human essence can be freed from its alienation. Althussers critique of theoretical humanism the grounding of althussers critique of humanism lies not as one would at first think in some traditional marxist opposition to the entire ethical prob lematic.
For, if althusser has thought it necessary to challenge those tendencies humanism, historicism, hegelianism which have haunted western marxism since lukacss early work and become powerfully influential in the last two decades, it is because he believes that, being theoretically deficient, they cannot but. Althusser and theoretical antihumanism public group. In addition, scientific marxism, particularly a s constructed by althusser, perhaps its most sophisticated proponent mclellan 1975. Marxism, althusser, theoretical antihumanism, antiessentialist. Whatever atrocities stalin committed were on the humanist ground, that he exercised his rational choice. Is althussers marxism a degenerating research program. John lewis was sitting in the front row of the audience. When eventually a marxist policy of humanist ideology, that is, a political attitude to humanism, is achieved a policy which may be either a rejection or a.
Althusser also rejected the idea of a marxist humanism which had become popular after the 1953 death of joseph stalin. In the earlier model, ideology was believed to create what was termed false consciousness, a false understanding of the way the world functioned for example, the suppression of the fact that. Louis althusser was a french marxist philosopher who had a. To althusser, this also appeared to be an important point within the debates internal to communism at the time, in that it was dominated by the ideological complex he called humanism and economism. Althusser identifies every aspect of marxism that stalinism had elevated to orthodox marxism with hegel. A rare exception was his april 1980 appearance on the italian radio television rai program multimedia encyclopaedia of the philosophical sciences. One feature of althusserian marxism is a rejection of marxs hegelian essentialism.
Jun 24, 2016 althussers version of marxism rejects both economic determinism and humanism. In the text entitled marxism and humanism, dating from 1963, i have already interpreted the present inflation of the themes of marxist or socialist humanism as an ideological phenomenon. Louis althusser combined marxism with the scientifically oriented methods of structuralism in his essay, ideology and the ideological state apparatuses 1970 and analysed how the dominant systems enforce their control by subtly. However, one will nd in my essay marxism and humanism, as well as in. The trajectory of such movements was away from marxism as a science to an increasing concern with ethical prob lems. Presentation of althusser in the first half of the 20th century marxist theory was dominated by. As it enters the period which will lead it from socialism to each according to his labour to communism to each according to his needs, the soviet union has proclaimed the slogan. On it alone can marxism base a policy in relation to the existing ideological forms, of every kind. Althusser s critique of theoretical humanism the grounding of althusser s critique of humanism lies not as one would at first think in some traditional marxist opposition to the entire ethical prob lematic. There can be no wonder that confusion has reigned over the political interpretation of althusser s early theoretical work. For sure, the ethical humanism alienation themes of the early marx 1844 belong to a premarxist problematic that is still governed by feuerbachian and hegelian concerns. Louis althusser 19181990 french marxist philosopher. Althussers influential attack on marxism and the concepts of dialectical development in nature and history. Althusser ideology and ideological state apparatuses summary of althussers text ideology and ideological state apparatuses last document update.
Colletti in italy, the marxists of functionalistic analysis coming up later in the us and the uk and so on, among whom althusser is the first to put forward a call to arms with a clear idea to fight for marx with a scientific position. In the latter, althusser really lays out the argument that ideology is always present, which is a notion many who might attempt to contrast ideology with pragmatism might have never even thought about. In the latter, althusser really lays out the argument that ideology is always present, which is a notion many who might attempt to contrast ideology with. Rather, althusser claims his opposition has an epistemological foundation. Jul 11, 2017 louis althusser did not often given television interviews. Paradoxically, it is the french philosopher louis althusser 191890, who has often been charged with transposing marxism into an academic pursuit removed from actual workers struggles, who furnishes two rejoinders to this impatience with marxist philosophy. He was born in algeria and studied at the ecole normale superieure in paris, where he eventually became professor of philosophy.
The french theorist louis althusser 19181990 was wellknown for his antihumanist marxism, where his essay marxism and humanism 1964 condemns ideas like human potential and speciesbeing, which are often put forth by marxists, considering them as an outcome of a bourgeois ideology of humanity. For sure, the ethical humanismalienation themes of the early marx 1844 belong to a premarxist problematic that is still governed by. Louis althusser was a french marxist philosopher who had a strong following. In the 1960s althusser pursued a rigorous project and tried to develop a systematic account of philosophy, history, and science from within marxisman account that would constitute a theoretical weapon against hegelian idealism. Louis althusser, french philosopher who attained international renown in the 1960s for his attempt to fuse marxism and structuralism. Concerning humanism, sartre, anti humanism, and althusser disclaimer. I have only read a few works by sartre, and nothing by althusser. Lewis writes in louis althusser and the tradtions of french marxism, garaudys project after 1956 was to show how marxism is not only a humanism but a theory of human liberation compatible with judeochristian notions of emancipation, and thus also a practical basis for uniting with catholics and social democrats. The latter argues that the social organization in which human beings live is driven by. For sure, the ethical humanism alienation themes of the early marx 1844 belong to a pre marxist problematic that is still governed by feuerbachian and hegelian concerns. The former places the human being as a creative individual at the centre of the dialectical process, hence, humanist. Does this later, scientific, marxism really make sense, given the relative obscurity of marxist ideas.
995 6 1336 560 440 547 341 557 1467 1063 1093 1137 164 1361 1083 566 392 1244 378 116 1329 1391 991 805 1225 1503 964 932 172 758 1353 338 397 891 1397 596